We had dinner at the on-sight restaurant. The meals were out of this world. We had the grouper and triple tail. Katie B. made us feel at home the second we walked in to the place. it was off season, we experieance excellent service, we also had time to talk to the staff. They were so ‘Chill’, whatever we wanted they would accommodate. Chef Pete came to our table to make sure our meal was what we expected. The food, the staff, the experience was so good we just went back the second night and their hospitality was just as good as the night before. These people love their jobs and it was evident to us. Josh behind the bar, Katie B. as the waitstaff, Chef Pete hit a homer on our 2 night stay.
Read Full Review
Write a Review
This is the second year that we stayed here. We reserve the doll house cottage a.k.a. honeymoon cottage for our 17th anniversary and I cannot say enough how friendly all the staff were any accommodations were perfect. I would definitely like to give a shout out to Tracy in the gift shop and Josh in the bar and Scott and Marla in the restaurant and Mark the manager you guys were all awesome. Can’t wait to come back. See ya next year.
Read Full Review
Write a Review
If you haven’t been to Cabbage Key – Hurry up and get there! Life is too short to not experience this place. Great drinks, great service, great management, great food, great fun! You may have to wait to get a Burger…but the bar is always open!! After all, this is the most popular island in SWF! Get a Cabbage Creeper and some STONE CRAB CLAWS! YUM!!
Read Full Review
Write a Review
We stayed in the Dollhouse Cottage to celebrate our 5 year wedding anniversary. From the moment we arrived until the moment we left we were treated wonderfully and accommodated extremely well. Debi was our server both nights when we ate at The restaurant on the island, she was WONDERFUL and the food was beyond delicious. I have not one complaint about our stay. It was perfect!
We WILL be back!
Read Full Review
Write a Review
Took a boat ride to Cabbage Key. My first visit. Rebecca was our waitress. She was great! Friendly service. Delicious food. Wonderful view. Can’t wait to go back and see if my dollar bill has fallen from the wall! Thanks for the memory! You must go! Right now!
Read Full Review
Write a Review
We stayed two nights in the Dollhouse and it was wonderful. Bed was comfortable and cottage was very clean and quaint. Loved having our own pier!! The staff told us that we would enjoy watching the ‘boat parade’ from our pier. It was amazing!! Starting at about 10:30, boats started filing in to park and eat at the restaurant. The dock master was something to see!! We spent hours sipping Bloody Marys and enjoying the show.
We ate at the restaurant breakfast, lunch and dinner and all were excellent. Wait staff couldn’t have been friendlier. We’ve stayed in the FL Keys and this is even more Old School than that. Very quiet and relaxing.
Read Full Review
Write a Review
Our family enjoyed the beautiful Snook Cottage for three nights to celebrate my Mom’s birthday weekend. The cottage was cozy and included all the amenities needed for a nice long weekend with family; we anchored our two boats right down our dock which was perfect for our daily dose of vitamin sea. The Inn itself is just beautiful and the entire island reminds you of true old Florida – it’s the perfect place to visit with friends and family.
Read Full Review
Write a Review
Took a boat from Pine Island and went to the restaurant for lunch on 8/12. Shrimp salad was excellent. Party of 8 ladies who have been friends since high school received awesome service. Our server Rebecca was outstanding. She even took time to take a few group pictures for us. Management was helpful as well and very attentive. Thank you Rebecca for such a great day.
Read Full Review
Write a Review
Absolutely LOVE this place! Beautiful views, great drinks, wonderful staff, fabulous food and a terrific little marina. A great escape if you actually like to “unplug” and are able to enjoy what a private island has to offer. Romantic. quiet and gorgeously natural.
Read Full Review
Write a Review
During the last week of June and the first week of July we visited Cabbage Key on numerous occasions. Taking each visit different guests from Europe and other parts of the US. On each trip we were a minimum of 10 people and the service, welcome and food were worth out doubt perfect! Clam chowder is awesome, shrimp salad, hamburger, chicken sandwich all superb – and the rice and beans always a treat!!! Our guests all loved it. Big thanks to Marlene,Dorothy and Stella and of course everyone else on the island. Also mention for Jeff and Joe who always ensure us a safe berth. A must visit if you can – see you soon Jeremy and Sue … MY Hillo
Read Full Review
Write a Review
